Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[LoveMetal]

To be in the hall of fame, probably.

I found the last version of the player list I made, as he said Shroob has been killed the night he wanted to post that in public.

/!\ Even if you see someone marked as an elf on the list it's maybe untrue, because there is an acolyte that have the power to send an elf PM when he is inspected.
That's why I sent it to the 3 people that I'm really sure they are reliable: Sierra, Hallelujah and Goldfish.

•Aviator - DEAD - Elf. It was the Guardian.
•Echidna - Posted a lot in the thread. Just sent me his PM, he can redirect a night action.
•Skyscraper - Sent his role PM to Sierra because I asked him but he didn't think I was reliable. Seems like he can block a night action.
•Gregorio - Don't know anything about him.
•A Capella - Don't know anything about him, except that he wanted to lynch since the first day, don't know if it was irony though. Also he publicly suggested to the guardian to protect Sierra, which could be seen as a suspicious move because then the mafia could focus on someone else. And they killed Ping Pong.
•Goldfish - Elf, inspected and sent to me his role PM by his own initiative. He can force Humch to write something in the thread when the night is over and he proved that he has that ability.
•Humpty Dumpty - Don't know anything about him. Pineapple wanted to lynch him with no reasons but he reacted very peacefully in public.
•Ping Pong - DEAD - Elf, vote counts twice.
•Pineapple - Elf, inspected and sent his PM. Seems like he can redirect a night action except from the killing ones.
•Lakitu - DEAD - Elf, can block the night action of a player.
•Sierra - Elf, Sultan's brother.
•Sultan - DEAD - Elf, Sierra's brother.
•Hallelujah - Elf, it's the inspector. Told me that Goldfish, Pineapple, Super Star and myself were Elves because he inspected us.
•Hamlet - I'm like 90% sure he's an elf, we talked since the very beginning. However there is always a small chance of him being an acolyte, and he knows a lot about people abilities. His role would be that he can't being lynched, but his role PM looks somewhat weird. He gave me good advices though.
•Bartholomew - LOLELF, can kill one player every night.
•Diplodocus - Looks sincere in his stupidity so I'd say Elf but I still unsure.
•Super Star - Elf, he was inspected.

[Bradandez]

Aw sweet. Not even you guys knew what I was up to.

[LoveMetal]

Aw sweet. Not even you guys knew what I was up to.

You never answered to my requests. Also I tried to kill you, I think.
The only mafioso I tried to kill was Gregorio, but I was redirected again.

[Bradandez]

Anything's possible with Jesus by my side.

[NyaNyaLily]

Everyone thought I was quilty because I could redirect night actions Hooray for dying!

[Hunchman801]

Nah, I win. I lived so I win. I don't what anyone else says, I win.

Well actually the mafia's victory condition is to eliminate all the villagers, so just consider that the game was shortened.

[Shrooblord]

Here is the exact post I was going to publish:

A mysterious piece of paper flutters through the air. What is it? Hand-written notes containing detailed information about the elves! This could prove most useful to the survivors.

•Aviator - DEAD - Elf: Guardian.
•Echidna - DEAD - Elf:Rudolph. Diverts night-time actions.
•Skyscraper - ??? - Can block a night-time action?
•Gregorio - ??? - UNKNOWN
•A Capella - ??? - Protected from the Mafia.
•Goldfish - Elf: Herald; spreads rumours at night.
•Humpty Dumpty - ??? - UNKNOWN; Note: Pineapple wanted to lynch him with no reasons but he reacted very peacefully in public.
•Ping Pong - DEAD - Elf: vote counts twice.
•Pineapple - Elf - UNKNOWN
•Lakitu - DEAD - Elf: can block the night action of a player.
•Sierra - Elf: Sultan's brother.
•Sultan - DEAD - Elf: Sierra's brother.
•Hallelujah - Elf: can evade one night-time action.
•Hamlet - DEAD - Elf: Evades lynching.
•Bartholomew - Elf: can kill one player every night.
•Diplodocus - ???, presumed Elf - UNKNOWN.
•Super Star - DEAD - Elf: butcher; can find out the killer of an elf.

[Harpic fraîcheur]

mh.. nice to see there is a dead list.

[Hunchman801]

Well everyone's dead/alive status was public...

[Jewish Candy]

There were lots of reasons to lynch us that were never acknowledged.

Apart from incognito's first move, what were they?

On my part, the fake role PM I wrote was more in the style of Des than Humch - ie., verbose rather than short - and I used the name Belsnickel, which should have set alarm bells ringing as it's unlike all the other cheery elf names that I was unaware of. Also, I claimed to be the blocker the very night before the real blocker was killed. It's bizarre this wasn't noted...

More generally, we killed Sultan on the first night, thereby clearing Sierra's name very early and allowing him to organise the elves into a cohesive force (an opportunity which he did not take). We didn't kill the most crucial roles until the late game, including the bloody inspector, and our suspicions about who had which role were often wrong. Dip diced with death a LOT. Honestly, if it wasn't for Lovy, there's no way we could have won. You're our honorary sixth ranger!

[Bradandez]

Nah, I win. I lived so I win. I don't what anyone else says, I win.

Well actually the mafia's victory condition is to eliminate all the villagers, so just consider that the game was shortened.

Or that the Mafia failed in killing everyone? I win. I win. I win, I win, I WIN!

[Jewish Candy]

Humch stole our victory from us!!

[NyaNyaLily]

HUNCH!

[Hunchman801]

And finally... the best and worst players of this game.

Hall of Fame

1. buildersith (Pineapple)
   Builder was the mole. He successfully infiltrated the villagers' small resistance circle, all while leading the mafia's strategy. His decisions led his team to an overwhelming victory.
2. Jewish Candy (Skyscraper)
   Candish joined the game rather early, and took part in devising the mafia's strategy as well, especially when poor builder ended up in the hospital.

Hall of Fail

1. emshomar (Sierra)
   Emsh was lucky enough to be cleared of any suspicion very early in the game, when his twin brother died, revealing that he was not a mafioso. He could have taken this opportunity to request everyone's role PM, and maybe even lead the village, but he did none of these, leaving his team weak and disorganized.
2. Incognito (Gregorio)
   Inco's only contribution to the game was the incredibly boonworthy use of his night action on a fellow mafioso, raising suspicion on him and jeopardizing the survival of his team. He was then kicked out for inactivity and replaced by roles.
3. Imco97 (Aviator)
   Imco (almost?) never replied to any messages he received, attempting to win this game solo. He hardly ever used his power either, de facto depriving the village from a protector.

[Imco]

Hooray! I'm in the Hall of Fail! That's a good thing, right? RIGHT?!

[MrBadGuy]

Depending on the reasons for being there, it can be a good thing

[Jewish Candy]

But where is Lovy?! Fame or Fail, whatever, he was integral to the progression of the game.

[MrBadGuy]

Nah, he's too dovy

[Snagglebee]

At least got the first place on something

[Master]

Well deserved ovation for Builder and Candy, well done fellas, we wouldn't have won without ya