Rate that signature!

[Serza5]

Who else thinks my sig is super sexy?

[Master]

Hmm, with RD over, and finally able to see sigs, it looks pretty good.

Sadly, I've no clue as to who that is, but the general design is good. The text itself could stand out a little more though, 8/10.

[Harpic fraîcheur]

Who else thinks my sig is super sexy?

I'll give a 9/10 to your sexy sig.

[incognito]

Small, but for the source of the quote I give a 8/10

[Adsolution]

5 / 10 - The photographs themselves are actually really nice, but white flow around them, the background and especially the blue text don't blend.

[NyaNyaLily]

8/10

I don't know, but your sigs always make me think Rayman goes beserk and kills everyone.

[The_Real_Razorbeard]

A bit on the large side, but, as a fan of Pizza and a dirty memer, I approve. 10/10

[Master]

Quoting in need of feedback:

Alright then, before I switch to it, I'd like to see if this is any better now:

Man, I forgot I started my current sig as an entry in a Xmas Sig contest, pity I didn't find these sooner, they fit with the current winter RPC theme.

Well, you've changed into a regeneration, pretty decent rendition indeed, 9/10.

Speaking of which, I've been working on my more permanent sig, I'd like to hear what you guys think of this one before I do anything with:
Original Size:


Signature Size:

Hm, yeah, the red of Gallifrey doesn't really work well with the blues of the other locations. Lemme see to that:

Wow, it's been just over three years now since I made this sig. I'm thinking I should probably make a change at this point, but what to do, hm? I still very much like all the series that feature in my sig, but there are plenty more I've come to like since. I'm thinking I should do something more representative of myself rather than what I like. But at the same time, I do want to have that Sci-Fi touch I've had in most of my old sigs, I just found this old one that I did based off the Metroid logo:

[Adsolution]

I think it'd be really great to see a new signature on you. I think my favourite was still the Metroid one!

[Master]

Hmm, I think the problem with the Metroid one is the jagged edges. I remember back when I was Master4lyf1, I had one based off the Doctor Who logo, with the icon and all. I can't seem to find it, so I'm guessing that one's lost for good.

I think I'll take a look at what I've had thus far, and see where I can go from there.

[Adsolution]

why is "hot" in quotes?

[Ambidextroid]

@Master I've always wondered what some of the images are, I can see the Tardis in M, the Fairy Council in A and Sandover Village in R but I've never been able to clock what the other three are

[Master]

Argh, still need to get round to making a new sig. As for your question:

M - Matt Smith's Second TARDIS interior (I ought to see I can get Capaldi's TARDIS interior if I do this again with a new sig)
A - The Fairy Council
S - Planet Cybertron, homeworld of the Transformers
T - Phaaze, the source of Phazon, the dangerous substance that was the driving force behind the Metroid Prime Trilogy
E - The Great Clock, from Ratchet and Clank: A Crack in Time.
R - Sandover Village, from Jak and Daxter: The Precursor Legacy.

[Ambidextroid]

Ah, I was almost certain that was Ratchet and Clank but I didn't want to get it wrong
Which reminds me, I should try making a RaC signature to add to the pile. I was also planning on a Rayman 3 signature but I've tried before and got almost nowhere, replicating that lettering is bloody difficult but it's probably my all time favorite logo so I've got to do it eventually

[Harpic fraîcheur]

10/10!!!

It looks like the pirate has poo on his head

[Master]

Bumping. I decided to try making a new proper replacement sig, this is what I've got thus far:

[Ambidextroid]

I really the typeface and Gallifreyan design inside the text but I think the edges are a little off, it looks as though there's a subtle white/grey border of pixels that look kind of out of place, maybe because the shadows on the embossment suddenly meet a white glow and it looks kind of unnatural. One other thing (that I might just be imagining) is that the skew of the text looks slightly off to the left. That's not really a critique though, I'm just wondering if it was intentional or not.

[Master]

Fair points, the reason why it looks a little skewed, I'm guessing is due to how the typeface itself skews. I went and changed it so that the letters are symmetrical, and gave the sig another shot.

Attempt 1:


Attempt 2:

[Ambidextroid]

That second attempt is really nice, I like the colour more although the grey in the centre looks a little out of place. Maybe it could do with a bit of a shadow below it too, though it's hard to visualise it in my head so I can't tell if that'd be an improvement or not.
If you changed the centre to match the hue or made the gradient a little more subtle I think you'd have a really nice sig!

[Serza5]

I agree with Ambis point about the 2nd sig having the same hue all around. It's really hard to read the "s" especially on rpcs background.