SOTM#170 - Rayman Legends

[Serza5]

This one MUST be accepted

Ok then tell me; why EXACTLY do you think I should allow this sig to be accepted? In as much detail as possible preferably.

[OCG]

Ok, I will try to tell with detail.
First signature that Imco did was a Gangnam Style parody with Rayman dressed as a PSY. In Imco's eyes and also mine, it looked perfect because it was cool but also on indirect way matched the theme. Like I did say before and Dart agrees, since Rayman was dressed as PSY, and PSY is gentleman, Rayman should automatically be one too. But you denied it with possibly ok reason because you thought it was not enough. Then Imco tried fixing signature by adding some more details to make Rayman look like gentleman (he edited it two times). Not only does Rayman now look like gentleman by finishing touches but he is also dressed as PSY so he is like a double gentleman. As for extra details, when looking at Dart's Rayman and Imco's Rayman in last edit, there is similarity so if Dart's signature is allowed, Imco's signature meets more than enough for standards. Rayman, having typical gentleman stuff and also dressed as PSY = double gentleman.

I hope this was enough for details.

[Shrooblord]

I just think you're trying to push it a little too far. The host doesn't want to accept your entry since it doesn't conform to the rules - don't try to dodge them and worm its way into the entries. That only makes your actions look bad and, in effect, makes your entry look bad.
Try something new, use this sig as your own, go hug a kitten - pretty much anything but this, I'd wager.

[Serza5]

Ok, I will try to tell with detail.
First signature that Imco did was a Gangnam Style parody with Rayman dressed as a PSY. In Imco's eyes and also mine, it looked perfect because it was cool but also on indirect way matched the theme. Like I did say before and Dart agrees, since Rayman was dressed as PSY, and PSY is gentleman, Rayman should automatically be one too. But you denied it with possibly ok reason because you thought it was not enough. Then Imco tried fixing signature by adding some more details to make Rayman look like gentleman (he edited it two times). Not only does Rayman now look like gentleman by finishing touches but he is also dressed as PSY so he is like a double gentleman. As for extra details, when looking at Dart's Rayman and Imco's Rayman in last edit, there is similarity so if Dart's signature is allowed, Imco's signature meets more than enough for standards. Rayman, having typical gentleman stuff and also dressed as PSY = double gentleman.

I hope this was enough for details.

Let me put it simply :
PSY's song "Gentleman" -> Gentleman themed
PSY's song "Gangnam Style" -> Not Gentleman themed

Your sig -> Uses the song "Gentleman"
Imco's sig -> Uses the song "Gangnam Style"

EDIT : As for Darts sig he gets in because he mostly has Rayman in a Gentleman suit while Imco's is more Gangnam style than "rayman in a suit".

[Imco]

Similar idea, different approach.

[Shrooblord]

Can't really deny that one, I don't think. That's a better effort!

[Serza5]

Hm, yes this one is acceptable.

[Shrooblord]

By the way, Master, you should totally use that top hat as your sig occassionally. ;D

[Master]

Hmm, you think? It was a bit of a quick job, but I guess I could put it on now and then if I'm feeling classy, hehe.

[Serza5]

Couldn't think of a more classier Rayman character than Razoff himself. Also the walking cane is there to fill up space; it was going to be a tea cup but I gave up trying to render that.

[Shrooblord]

I could imagine the other end of Razoff's gun being a walking cane handle, so he could use it to walk around difficult terrain or perhaps reel in or shove away distant and close prey. Nice!

[Dart]

EDIT : As for Darts sig he gets in because he mostly has Rayman in a Gentleman suit while Imco's is more Gangnam style than "rayman in a suit".

Looks like I made it in!

[Bradandez]

Im sure Brad could do a good Gangnam Ray

I shall do no such thing.

Anyways, I will be making an entry this time!

[Dart]

Good to hear! any idea's on what you'll be drawing yet?

[Sny]

well i think i'll try an entry, too, this time :3

EDIT: done

(drawn by only me)
when razoff can be a gentleman so why not the paluchards, too?

[Serza5]

I say old bean, this is quite the turn out.

[PluMGMK]

That sig is hilarious!

[Master]

I can only echo Plum's sentiment, very well done, Sny!

[Sny]

yay, thank you, i'm glad you like it °w°

[Bradandez]

Nice entry, Sny.

Good to hear! any idea's on what you'll be drawing yet?

Jeez, some privacy, okaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay?