Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[Puruun]

Wow. That. Was. AWESOME!

When's the next game?

[El Dango]

That was one hell of an ending. Sabertooth ftw!

[Matyuv]

First of all great job HC on hosting the game!
I enjoyed watching the game process ( was extra fun because I knew who the mafia were too ) and I'm definitely looking forward to a new one, perhaps a Rayman themed one first? There's plenty of different characters that could be used.

[Matyuv]

Good thing I escaped before Saber could get me.

o btw maybe we could invite Jona
I don't really understand why MLII wasn't playing too

[PluMGMK]

Maybe if you're represented by your avatar...

[Matyuv]

It's quite obvious who the bad guys are then

[El Dango]

I enoyed the game. Too bad I fucked up.

[PluMGMK]

It's quite obvious who the bad guys are then

Who said bad guys represent mafia and vice versa?

[Hunchman801]

I don't like the ending

[PluMGMK]

I don't like what happened to these two topics when they got merged.

[Matyuv]

It's quite obvious who the bad guys are then

Who said bad guys represent mafia and vice versa?

Well I think that makes more sense than the opposite of that.

It isn't the only problem though -- the hoster will know who he's writing a role for, which kind of ruins one the game concepts that roles have to be drawn randomly I believe; plus it's quite obvious that a Reflux should be more powerful than a Matuvu don't you think? Which increases his chances to be lynched.

[PluMGMK]

Then there are unlynchable ranks, like Moskito. Okay, bad idea.

[Hunchman801]

It was fixed. I'm unsure whether there should be only one topic for the next mafia games, but in any case one per game is enough

As concerns feedback... well yeah it was pretty awesome, but I have a couple suggestions. First of all, the each turn shouldn't last more than 24 hours, whether everyone has voted or not. This is why we should have motivated players. Also, some of our active members haven't played the first game, which is a shame, and we should definitely ask them.

[Matyuv]

As concerns feedback... well yeah it was pretty awesome, but I have a couple suggestions. First of all, the each turn shouldn't last more than 24 hours, whether everyone has voted or not..

Well then a minimum amount of votes is required, how about 50% of players?

[Hunchman801]

With motivated players, we should always get more than 50% of the votes in 24 hours. Well, I hope so

[Sabertooth]

I agree that the wait was a little too long each day, but we need enough time to vote, at least. I go on here every day after school, but usually a lot of people have posted while I was in school, either because of our times zones or the fact that most of you are adults. Either way, we should keep it at at least 12 hours.

[MLII]

I don't really understand why MLII wasn't playing too

I didn't feel like it tbh.

...

Alright I read the rules and I didn't understand them I kinda get it now though

[Hunchman801]

12 hours makes it hard for people who can only visit PC once a day, after work or school for example. However I like the idea of speed mafia games, which could be played in one or two days.

[PluMGMK]

I didn't feel like it either. I soon wished I had signed up though.

[Tobbe]

However, Tobbe didn't need a powerful role. He was probably one of the best players in this game, doing almost everything right.

I loved this game, particularly because I played it so well and won the whole thing. I think you did a very good job hosting it, HC, cred to you for that. I don't have any particular suggestions as to what can be improved, but I definitely wanna play more rounds.

I'm pretty sure that I could host a game sometime in the future as well. I'd much rather be a godlike gamemaster than a lowly villager!

btw: Serza decided to entice me instead of sabertooth because Hunch convinced her to, so that wasn't a fortunate coincidence, but yet another well calculated move by the Mafia.