Sabertooth1000000000 wrote:I'm not sure if this has to do with lore precisely, but rather continuity. This is just a commonly debated section of the canon that I'd like to get my theory out for:
The André in Rayman 3 is not the same André in Rayman: Hoodlums' Revenge.
Although it has been debated numerous times, I still believe that the final scene from Rayman 3 was a flashback, not a cliffhanger. You can tell because it's made clear that the moons (yeah, why are there two moons?) are in drastically different positions at the start of the game than the end. Therefore, André is still a red lum as of the end of Rayman 3.
But that leads me to Rayman: Hoodlums' Revenge, and yes, I do believe that this game is canon (if Rayman 1 can be explained into continuity, this certainly can). A lot of sources claim that André "returned" in this game and Rayman had to fight him off again. But no- if you pay close attention to the dialogue, it's implied that after André left Globox's stomach, he left behind a piece of himself. This piece of him is not the same André that was currently floating around as a red lum at that time, but rather a divided part of his soul that he left just in case Reflux failed. He somehow called back the black lums (magic damn you) and the hoodlums returned to resurrect Reflux using plumjuice. Rayman defeated Reflux for the sixth time, André's soul was cast out of Globox, and they carried on with their lives.
So while it is unclear as to what exactly happened to Mister Dark and Razorbeard, I'm fairly certain that André is still a nonvocal, innocent red lum floating around in the Fairy Council.
André was not physically present in Globox’s body during the events of Rayman: Hoodlums’ Revenge. It seems that he detatched a portion of his soul before the Teensie doctors could extract him, and this portion gained consciousness at some point while André’s physical form was floating around somewhere as a Red Lum. The soul fragment gradually took possession of Globox and turned him into a Reflux clone. When Rayman defeated it, the soul fragment (which is now seen for the first time, and looks like a glowing orb of purple mist) fled, possibly to rejoin the Red Lum that is André and merge with it, opening the way for André to return in a future game.
Sabertooth1000000000 wrote:One last thing: while this has nothing to do with my theory, I think that we should forget all about Raving Rabbids 1-TV Party and instead consider the GBA RRR canon in their place. Who's with me on this?
I’m all for forgetting that RRR1–TV Party were ever developed, but I’m not sure if RRR1 GBA is really a worthy installment in the series. As a game, it’s mediocre. As far as continuity goes, it has a weak story and fucks around with the number of Lums.
I would be willing to accept it as canonical if someone could come up with a good theory explaining why there appear to by 1550 Lums instead of 1000. That’a pretty blatant contridiction of Rayman 2.
I also think it’s possible that R3 GBA is canon and takes place between R2 and R3.