Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[Diplodocus]

I'm very sorry for being so silent, I do understand that the village needs communication, I will work on this.
I myself am not suspecting anyone at the moment, but I do find it odd Echidna hasn't posted anything yet.
I think we should indeed let the investigator check the most suspicious after we have a confirmation Pineapple is clean.
I wouldn't mind if I got inspected after pineapple.

[Pineapple]

Btw, why do you think people should mistake you for America?

Pineapple, your strategy seems pretty solid so far. However, I don't want anyone to completely overtake the village, as it would be very risky even if you are reliable. Therefore, I'll offer my help organizing the village with you.

Thank you for offering your help, Bart. I'll be glad to cooperate with you as soon as we both know we can trust each other

I hate to double post, I suggest the inspector tests either monopoly or diplodocus first. Pineapple is not the priority at the moment. He really wants to be tested, so I think inspecting him is just a waste of one night.

Either you trust me and cooperate immediately or you check me out to make sure I'm not a bad guy, but what kind of a strategy is that to delay the investigation and therefore the cooperation of the good guys just because I'm not 'suspicious enough'? At one point, you have to make sense

Thank you to all those who agree that inspecting me first is a good idea. Hopefully this will be done quickly and we'll be able to start real investigations.

[Paintball]

I hate to double post, I suggest the inspector tests either monopoly or diplodocus first. Pineapple is not the priority at the moment. He really wants to be tested, so I think inspecting him is just a waste of one night.

Either you trust me and cooperate immediately or you check me out to make sure I'm not a bad guy, but what kind of a strategy is that to delay the investigation and therefore the cooperation of the good guys just because I'm not 'suspicious enough'? At one point, you have to make sense

You are either the mole or a good guy. If you are inspected, in both cases the inspector will receive the role you posted and thus, won't receive new information. If people of whom the identity is unknown are investigated first, now that'd be new information. Why are you so focused on proving your innocence first if we all know we will just come to know something we already know and still can't trust for sure?

Inspector, I invite you to inspect me. I'm sure you won't regret it. I feel sorry for you though, so many people to choose from..

[Pineapple]

The mole's fake skill can easily be proved wrong, while I asked the vigilante to try and kill me tonight so that I can definitely clear any doubts on my identity. As much as I trust in your good will, please do not undermine a strategy which will allow us to organise ourselves much earlier than by simply inspecting suspicious players and then realising that nothing can be done against them.

[Paintball]

The mole's fake skill can easily be proved wrong, while I asked the vigilante to try and kill me tonight so that I can definitely clear any doubts on my identity. As much as I trust in your good will, please do not undermine a strategy which will allow us to organise ourselves much earlier than by simply inspecting suspicious players and then realising that nothing can be done against them.

Well then, why not let the inspector investigate someone else? If the vigilante fails to kill you tonight, that should be enough evidence right?

[Super Star]

I agree with Paint Ball, that we should try to get new information, and just believe Canada for now. Trust him for now, and if things go wary later, keep an eye on him.

Why waste an investigation on him? Most likely, Mafia won't try to kill Canada since he'll appear like a ghost to them, so why not have the doc NOT protect Pineapple, since he cannot be killed at night.

Just use your investigation on an inactive or the most suspicious to you.

Canada, don't you want to find scum? Why shouldn't we trust you? I don't think we need to cop you tonite.

[Sierra]

Day 1: no lynch.

[Echidna]

No Lynch.

[Goldfish]

It's not about believing Pineapple, it's about being willing to share information and develop plans with him. If we just accept him and give him our role PMs, he will be able to use the information to kill the most powerful player if he is an Axis.

[Diplodocus]

However, it doesn't really matter who gets inspected first, because we can 'build bridges' from any of the good guys.
So if Paintball gets inspected and we know he/she is clean, we can just start from there aswell.
So we could inspect the most suspicious, and if we know he/she is clean, we can all send him/her our roles anyway, wouldn't we?

[Skyscraper]

What?
You're all searching for the most suspicious player?
Sorry, but i think that the real axis exists of people who have posted here atleast once or twice.
Maybe even more, from what i've learned from the previous games, mafioso's always try to NOT be suspicious.
Which leave's villagers on the ''suspicious'' list.

I think we should inspect normal people for now.

[Diplodocus]

But don't you think we need to know a clean person so we have someone we can trust?
And then we can all send our pm's and under his/her leadership, we will bann those Axis out.
When we have a small group that's able to trust eachother, we can smoothly erase all Axis, but when we inspect someone and know he is an Axis, we still don't know who to trust.

[Skyscraper]

Maybe, but if i look at Pineapple's 'Role PM', it looks like he/she is that one person.
And i really think that the mafia has already 'blend in' this village.

[Diplodocus]

I understand that, but if we have someone who we can trust, he can lead a group he seems trustworthy, and he/she can decide everything with the people he /she trusts, while the others shall be lynched.

[Mafia Host]

The debates were intense today, and many now see to be following Pineapple. Most countries think things shouldn't be rushed, so once again, no one died. But can the Allied truly find out the Axis Powers that way ?

Night 1 begins now ! You'd better send me your NA !

[Pineapple]

Unless the Axis powers are complete morons, one of us is going down tonight, and this will be the case every night before we can organise ourselves. This is why I'll be repeating myself:

• If you are the inspector (a role which allows you to find out other players' role PMs), please check me out and contact me via PM when it's done.
• If you are the vigilante (a role which allows you to kill other players), please try to kill me and contact me via PM when it's done.

Then, we will start inspecting other players and either kill them if they are Axis or contact them if they are Allied. Players may be asked to prove their role in order to make sure they are not a mole (a role which allows a bad guy to camouflage as a good guy with a fake role PM).

Please do not make the same mistake you did on night 0 and help me organise the Allied forces.

[Super Star]

Unless the Axis powers are complete morons, one of us is going down tonight, and this will be the case every night before we can organise ourselves. This is why I'll be repeating myself:

• If you are the inspector (a role which allows you to find out other players' role PMs), please check me out and contact me via PM when it's done.
• If you are the vigilante (a role which allows you to kill other players), please try to kill me and contact me via PM when it's done.

Then, we will start inspecting other players and either kill them if they are Axis or contact them if they are Allied. Players may be asked to prove their role in order to make sure they are not a mole (a role which allows a bad guy to camouflage as a good guy with a fake role PM).

Please do not make the same mistake you did on night 0 and help me organise the Allied forces.

"one of us is going down tonight"

Do you have no interest in having someone protected in the night either? Do you not think there are doctors too?

[Sierra]

I don't think so or it would be very easy for us.
Pinnaple you said the NA had to protect you tonight but if he do, the inspector will not be able to ake his job =)
Are you trying to joke us? Hi hi hi

[Echidna]

"one of us is going down tonight"

Do you have no interest in having someone protected in the night either? Do you not think there are doctors too?[/quote]
the doctor cant protect everyone tho so someone will probs die so it doesnt matter who the doctor protects that much i guess

[Monopoly]

Sorry for not speaking much before, I'm not online much and I didn't have much to add that hadn't already been said in the topic.

I like Pineapple's plan, but I agree that it makes more sense to inspect someone else tonight and just let the vigilante check Pineapple. If he's still alive tomorrow, then we can trust him.