Mafia - Mafia Wins!

[Pineapple]

As much as I feel sorry for America, we shall celebrate the elimination of an Axis power so early in the game! This does, however, mean that the vigilante has not followed my advice, in which case I hope he knew what he was doing and had a real good reason to target Goldfish ; if he didn't, we were outrageously lucky tonight. As concerns the vigilante by the way, we have been able to identify him (90% sure) and I've sent him a PM.
I haven't been contacted by the inspector yet, I hope it's a question of response time, otherwise he probably earned himself a position in the Hall of Fail for being an obstacle to the coordination of the Allied forces.

I'll keep you guys in touch if anything new happens.

[Super Star]

It's not about believing Pineapple, it's about being willing to share information and develop plans with him. If we just accept him and give him our role PMs, he will be able to use the information to kill the most powerful player if he is an Axis.

With this line, i can see he's against Pineapple.

His first sentence is contradicted by the second.

Hey Pineapple, don't you get mistaken for America? *When America died* Why do you think that is? ;o

[Paintball]

It's not about believing Pineapple, it's about being willing to share information and develop plans with him. If we just accept him and give him our role PMs, he will be able to use the information to kill the most powerful player if he is an Axis.

With this line, i can see he's against Pineapple.

His first sentence is contradicted by the second.

Hey Pineapple, don't you get mistaken for America? *When America died* Why do you think that is? ;o

...

It all makes sense now.

[Sierra]

Can someone tell me which country are axis?
And stop intrepreting that much.
"Interpreting is not playing." M.S

[Super Star]

It's not about believing Pineapple, it's about being willing to share information and develop plans with him. If we just accept him and give him our role PMs, he will be able to use the information to kill the most powerful player if he is an Axis.

With this line, i can see he's against Pineapple.

His first sentence is contradicted by the second.

Hey Pineapple, don't you get mistaken for America? *When America died* Why do you think that is? ;o

...

It all makes sense now.

What do you mean?

[Paintball]

Well, I wasn't being that serious actually

It's just that I think having immortality at night might be a little unbalanced. He might have changed the text of his pm. It originally might have said that if somebody tried to kill Pineapple, America would be killed instead. That'd be unfair to America though. Maybe America got the option to sacrifice himself?

Remember, I'm just speculating.

[Skyscraper]

Can someone tell me which country are axis?
And stop intrepreting that much.
"Interpreting is not playing." M.S

All countries that were on Germany's side in the real life WWII are Axis.

[Super Star]

Well, I wasn't being that serious actually

It's just that I think having immortality at night might be a little unbalanced. He might have changed the text of his pm. It originally might have said that if somebody tried to kill Pineapple, America would be killed instead. That'd be unfair to America though. Maybe America got the option to sacrifice himself?

Remember, I'm just speculating.

So you think mafia tried to kill Canada, and instead killed America?

Why do you think it's unbalanced?

How is that unfair? Mafia kill. Wouldn't America rather stay alive?

[Paintball]

So you think mafia tried to kill Canada, and instead killed America?

Might have happened.

How is that unfair? Mafia kill. Wouldn't America rather stay alive?

It would be unfair if it was decided while writing the role pms that Canada's ability would be that America would die instead of him when Canada was targeted. And of course he wanted to stay alive!

Remember, I'm just speculating.

Why do you think it's unbalanced?

Being immortal at night certainly is one of the best abilities in the game. You can post your role without fear since most people will believe you, you won't get lynched.
Until the mafia outnumbers the villagers, you just won't die. It's perfect.

[Super Star]

So you think mafia tried to kill Canada, and instead killed America?

Might have happened.

How is that unfair? Mafia kill. Wouldn't America rather stay alive?

It would be unfair if it was decided while writing the role pms that Canada's ability would be that America would die instead of him when Canada was targeted. And of course he wanted to stay alive!

Remember, I'm just speculating.

Why do you think it's unbalanced?

Being immortal at night certainly is one of the best abilities in the game. You can post your role without fear since most people will believe you, you won't get lynched.
Until the mafia outnumbers the villagers, you just won't die. It's perfect.

Ah I see.

Ok, well if he wanted to stay alive, why would he sacrifice himself?

Hmmm, true. What do you think we should do toDay?

[Paintball]

Ah I see.

Ok, well if he wanted to stay alive, why would he sacrifice himself?

Hmmm, true. What do you think we should do toDay?

I was speculating~! Of course America has just been killed by the mafia directly. But if he did sacrifice himself he must've been controlled by someone else. But the whole sacrifice thing is highly unlikely.

[Super Star]

Ah I see.

Ok, well if he wanted to stay alive, why would he sacrifice himself?

Hmmm, true. What do you think we should do toDay?

I was speculating~! Of course America has just been killed by the mafia directly. But if he did sacrifice himself he must've been controlled by someone else. But the whole sacrifice thing is highly unlikely.

Speculating is good. Yeah I agree, if he sacrificed himself, then that would be three kills. Mafia kill, Suicide, and Vigilante.

So who do you find suspicious from yesterday?

Let's all talk about who should die toDay. (Someone from yesTerday I believe, we have info)

We can't No lynch forever. Luckily an Axis was killed yesTerday, but we can't expect the vigilante to kill correctly again, we need more discussion.

[Pineapple]

It's just that I think having immortality at night might be a little unbalanced. He might have changed the text of his pm. It originally might have said that if somebody tried to kill Pineapple, America would be killed instead. That'd be unfair to America though. Maybe America got the option to sacrifice himself?

If the dumb fuck who got the inspector role had contacted me earlier, no doubts would remain now. I'm the only player to have such an awesome ability which allows me to act as a bridge between true Allied forces, and so far two nights have been lost.

Anyone who feels like helping can send me a PM with the information they want, as I'm starting to fear that the inspector is not gonna do anything to help.

[Paintball]

"Two nights have been lost"? We already got rid of one axis!

[Pineapple]

Lost in terms of organisation. Germany's death is a great relief indeed.

[Sierra]

Let's all talk about who should die toDay. (Someone from yesTerday I believe, we have info)

We can't No lynch forever. Luckily an Axis was killed yesTerday, but we can't expect the vigilante to kill correctly again, we need more discussion.

Only an axis can talk like that thought...
Are you?

[Skyscraper]

Since this day is going NOWHERE, i'll just vote right now.

Day 2 - No lynch.

[Pineapple]

Guys, I have been contacted by a player who claims to be China, the bodyguard, i.e. someone with the ability to protect other players from night kills. If you are either China or the real bodyguard, which means I'm being tricked, please contact me asap. That person seems to be trustworthy, but I just can't take that chance.

As concerns today's vote, I have no good reasons to consider anyone Axis so far, but the five players who are not cooperating with me yet should move on if they don't want to be considered as such.

Day 2 - No lynch.

[Sierra]

I ever know a China and he is protector too.
By the way: Day2: no lynch

[Monopoly]

Day 2 - No lynch.