Hunch has requested I construct a Hall of Fame/Fail for my first game. Here it is, but remember that was ages ago; its not really in my memory and I no longer have the pms sent around etc, so it may not be the most accurate or comprehensive HoF.
HALL OF FAME!
3. Matyuv
Matyuv only spent a very short time playing before he was replaced by Hunch but what he achieved in this time is quite notable. He kidnapped Xenon, who was the inspector. It may have just been a lucky shot, but the removal of such a key villager started driving the Mafia towards an easy win as early as Night 1.
2. Hunchman801 Jr
He was apparently responsible for most of the Mafia's planning, and we all know how that worked out (if not: fucking awesomely). A notable decision was the one to sacrifice iHeckler to the village in order to gain their trust. Other than that, all Mafia members lived until the end of the game, quite a feat really. However, since this was Hunch's second life I felt it unfair to give him the number 1 position...
1. Tobbe
Tobbe also contributed to the Mafia's plans while simultaneously doing everything else right. A single joking comment made by him at the beginning lead to the Lynching of Good Hunch, the doctor and key villager, an act perhaps even more devastating than Xenon's kidnapping. He also used his ability quite well, although I maintain that the persuader as it was is a little broken in terms of balance.
HALL OF FAIL!
3. Serza
Serza, although she actually used her abilities unlike many others, did not use it particularly well. She even changed her mind one night in a way that could have stopped the Mafia killing but instead did nothing of value. She was also eaten... She didn't do too badly, she's just one of the only people who did enough stuff to actually fail at something.
2. El Dango
The Vigilante. He was going to pick off a Mafia member but changed his mind and killed a villager instead, as well as himself out of shame. This was on the same night as Serza's mistake; if that had both stuck with their original plan the Village would have taken a Mafia and lost no-one, instead of losing two of their own.
However, Dango does get plus points for faking his Role PM to hide his powerful role while gaining the villagers trust. It was reasonably well written too, almost confusing even me. He was the only one to do this too.
1. Xenon
Xenon spent most of the game kidnapped, which was out of his control. But even when he was able to be active he was more of a detriment despite his useful role. Firstly, he neglected to use his power on the first night, which may have found a Mafia or cleared one of the villagers who were stupidly Lynched. Speaking of stupidly lynching, Xenon was one of the most eager to Lynch good Hunch, a foolish choice early game, claiming that he was a "dead weight"and that you "had to lynch someone".
