Rate that signature!

[Shrooblord]

It's sigceptional!

[THEdragon]

8.5/10

Fashionable, functional, fashunctionable.

[OCG]

Just a question for Shrooblord. Is Razorbeard supposed to be animated or not? Because I don't see him animated but Mr. Dark was animated on previous signature. Chrome extensions are not always best.
Also THEdragon, I like your new signature and Rayman's faces 8/10
I would give it 10/10 if maybe background color had some effects or if there was something in background

[Master]

I think Razor is static, only Dark seems to have the gift to have his image granted movement, unless Razor is some Weeping Angel, and he's moving when you're not looking.
9/10 for OCG, it looks pretty good, but the logo could have a little more contrast to stick out more.

[Adsolution]

@Schrüb: 9.5/10 - Razor is an awesome addition to an awesome signature!

@THEdragon: 9/10 - The bright blue colour is the only thing that bugs me just a little bit. Other than that, j'adore the way you traced/drew Rayman's expressions!

[THEdragon]

8/10 Love the ROTD signature image, the model is great, although I did prefer the blue colour from the previous signature. Also, the "All hail King Comment" sign really throws off the signature.

[Bradandez]

9/10 I really didn't enjoy the blue background, but the transparent background with the added shadows make it look great!

[OCG]

@THEdragon
10/10 since it looks much better without blue Background.
@Brad
7/10
Looks funny and Crazy

[Rulez]

Also, the "All hail King Comment" sign really throws off the signature.

blasphemy

OCG is 8/10.

[Rayman fan2000]

Shrooblord, I saw that sig before, but I didn't have APNG installed, so I couldn't see that cool animation.

[Serza5]

Ok since this topic is getting some notice i'd like this sig i'm working on to be rated :



To put it simply i'm trying to find a new sig style I like working with, this is not quite what I had in my head but it's close enough to be somewhat satisfied. This is just a WIP so i'd like feedback on it and not just a rating if you please, and especially mention all the derp points about it.

[Master]

8.5/10, it looks pretty nifty, but there's something...off about it that I can't put my finger on.

[Adsolution]

I think there should be black borders on the bottom and top as well. Right now it looks kind of like the signature autocrop feature a lot of forums have.

[Serza5]

You mean like this Ads :


?

[Bradandez]

Looks better in my opinion.

[Stryj]

it captures a very specific emotion that I was never able to describe 10/10

[Rayman fan2000]

I don't know if anyone else sees this, but it kinda looks like it says "SERZAS."

[Serza5]

I can see what you mean. Tis nothing but a tester sig though as I could never replace my darling Wallace.

Your sig btw gets an 8/10; the text bothers me but otherwise pretty nice.

[Rulez]

Rayman Fan 2000, that's a pretty funny and okay sig, really, but the font pisses me off like no other. Change it and it'll be a rly ok sig !!!! :DDD

[Bradandez]

9/10 for drawing and dinojew