Rate that signature!
Forum rules
Please keep the forum rules and guidelines in mind when creating or replying to a topic.
Please keep the forum rules and guidelines in mind when creating or replying to a topic.
-
Snagglebee

- Posts: 11795
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2013 6:22 pm
- Location: Yes
- Tings: 2770
Re: Rate that signature!
Whoopsa, I did a typo, check again.
-
Master

- Posts: 53542
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2011 10:14 am
- Location: Somewhere specific, I'd assume.
- Tings: 468310
Re: Rate that signature!
Aha, a 9 then?
-
Snagglebee

- Posts: 11795
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2013 6:22 pm
- Location: Yes
- Tings: 2770
Re: Rate that signature!
Exactly 
-
Master

- Posts: 53542
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2011 10:14 am
- Location: Somewhere specific, I'd assume.
- Tings: 468310
Re: Rate that signature!
Aww, those plushie incarnations of your characters are pretty nice indeed, they're being used as 1-ups, if memory serves, right?
As for the sig, 10/10, brilliant.
As for the sig, 10/10, brilliant.
-
Snagglebee

- Posts: 11795
- Joined: Tue Jan 08, 2013 6:22 pm
- Location: Yes
- Tings: 2770
Re: Rate that signature!
@Brad: 9/10 for you.
Re: Rate that signature!
Skeptical Rayman is skeptical 9/10
-
Harpic fraîcheur

- Posts: 26130
- Joined: Sat Jan 18, 2014 7:57 pm
- Location: Au pays des prouts
- Tings: 375180
Re: Rate that signature!
@DandyGuy 7/10 it's a good 3d modelisation.
Re: Rate that signature!
Eh, still 4/10. Maybe 4.5 since you links in your sig.
Re: Rate that signature!
GeekOfTheGame 8.5/10
Bradandez 6.7/10
Dandy guy 6/10
Bradandez 6.7/10
Dandy guy 6/10
-
Harpic fraîcheur

- Posts: 26130
- Joined: Sat Jan 18, 2014 7:57 pm
- Location: Au pays des prouts
- Tings: 375180
Re: Rate that signature!
Incognito 8/10 The army style it's awesome !
Brad 2,5/10 The doll style it's...
Emsho. 8/10 you inspired of the teensies circle of Rayman Revolution ?
Brad 2,5/10 The doll style it's...
Emsho. 8/10 you inspired of the teensies circle of Rayman Revolution ?
-
Adsolution

- Posts: 22233
- Joined: Sat Aug 22, 2009 4:55 pm
- Contact:
- Tings: 110541
Re: Rate that signature!
8/10 - Awesome idea, I love the colours. The glow effect is chopped off and the text is barely readable, though.
It's what? I don't think anyone knows what you're thinking.GeekOfTheGame wrote:Brad 2,5/10 The doll style it's...
-
Master

- Posts: 53542
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2011 10:14 am
- Location: Somewhere specific, I'd assume.
- Tings: 468310
Re: Rate that signature!
Right then, for our ratings, let's see...
Dandy, 8/10, a decent render, if a tad simplistic.
Inco, 7/10, it's decent, but the way it's been cut looks horrid, if I'm being honest.
Geek, 7/10, also pretty decent, though that cutting of the glow and the text really does detract from it.
I'm pretty sure I've already rated Ad's, but I still must compliment Gwee for her brilliant Ly drawing, and Ad for putting it together so well.
Dandy, 8/10, a decent render, if a tad simplistic.
Inco, 7/10, it's decent, but the way it's been cut looks horrid, if I'm being honest.
Geek, 7/10, also pretty decent, though that cutting of the glow and the text really does detract from it.
I'm pretty sure I've already rated Ad's, but I still must compliment Gwee for her brilliant Ly drawing, and Ad for putting it together so well.
Re: Rate that signature!
It's what? I dislike it when people don't finish their sentences.GeekOfTheGame wrote:Brad 2,5/10 The doll style it's...
@GoG Given to your new sig, an 7/10. It's okay.
@incognito A 5/10.
I already rated Master's and Ad's signatures.
Re: Rate that signature!
Got myself one hell of a groovy signature. Rate it?
Also 1970 tings for whoever can guess all the references in my sig too! There's a total of four!
Also 1970 tings for whoever can guess all the references in my sig too! There's a total of four!
-
Adsolution

- Posts: 22233
- Joined: Sat Aug 22, 2009 4:55 pm
- Contact:
- Tings: 110541
Re: Rate that signature!
9/10. An absolutely awesome colour and look.
Maybe a bit stylistically conflicting though, the contrast between the realistic shading on the carvings and the flat characters in the front, and the amount of blur put on different objects is confusing: the records behind the characters are the most blurred, whereas the mushrooms behind them are blurred much less, and the characters in the front are perfectly sharp. It's rather confusing, and I think it obscures a sense of coherent depth the moment you actually focus on it for a second.
Maybe a bit stylistically conflicting though, the contrast between the realistic shading on the carvings and the flat characters in the front, and the amount of blur put on different objects is confusing: the records behind the characters are the most blurred, whereas the mushrooms behind them are blurred much less, and the characters in the front are perfectly sharp. It's rather confusing, and I think it obscures a sense of coherent depth the moment you actually focus on it for a second.
-
Harpic fraîcheur

- Posts: 26130
- Joined: Sat Jan 18, 2014 7:57 pm
- Location: Au pays des prouts
- Tings: 375180
Re: Rate that signature!
@Brad 8/10 Awesome sign *-*
Re: Rate that signature!
Geek's sig gets 7/10
The aspect ratio of Ales could have been better a bit, and I don't understand the text.
The aspect ratio of Ales could have been better a bit, and I don't understand the text.
-
Harpic fraîcheur

- Posts: 26130
- Joined: Sat Jan 18, 2014 7:57 pm
- Location: Au pays des prouts
- Tings: 375180
Re: Rate that signature!
OGC 8/10 Awesome sign 
Incognito 8,5/10 The style of the sign on the blood...

Incognito 8,5/10 The style of the sign on the blood...
Re: Rate that signature!
GOG: 6.5/10



