I don't agree. Eventhough it might not be too pleasant, you develop your own style by researching and copying the masters, let alone widen your knowledge about them and art in general. Completing tasks that others give you is also important, that's what design is about anyway.Xenon said:Researching artists and being told what to produce defeats the whole point in art and design - art, after all, is about originality and difference.
Sure, but that's how almost everyone (and designers in particular) work anyway, isn't it? They are given specific tasks and are paid for completing them.Xenon said:As for work production, I'm sure I'd get better grades if I chose to follow my own route rather than being given specific instructions, especially if my skills didn't lie in the task that was set.
Well, I would. Why not?Xenon said:I wouldn't research artists' work for the sole reason of gaining inspiration
Well designers are given broad instructions so they can develop their own ideas. Like creating a modern house, for example. Some workers are paid for completing very specific tasks though, and I still believe these people aren't working to the best of their ability. But with these jobs, the workers are being paid for 'completing tasks', if you like, and not creating a nice original product.Sure, but that's how almost everyone (and designers in particular) work anyway, isn't it? They are given specific tasks and are paid for completing them.
As I said, I'm speaking from a professional perspective. If I planned on becoming an artist and selling paintings I wouldn't draw a guy with a head of fruit because this has already been done (can't remember the artist's name). I feel I used the word 'inspiration' inappropriately, so apologies for that: really I just meant I wouldn't choose to copy styles or ideas from existing artists - I'd create my own.Well, I would. Why not?
I might be wrong but I believe that copying others' styles helps you develop your own style (requires quite a bit of talent too though).Xenon said:As I said, I'm speaking from a professional perspective. If I planned on becoming an artist and selling paintings I wouldn't draw a guy with a head of fruit because this has already been done (can't remember the artist's name). I feel I used the word 'inspiration' inappropriately, so apologies for that: really I just meant I wouldn't choose to copy styles or ideas from existing artists - I'd create my own.
Xenon said:Well designers are given broad instructions so they can develop their own ideas. Like creating a modern house, for example.
Xenon said:Some workers are paid for completing very specific tasks though, and I still believe these people aren't working to the best of their ability. But with these jobs, the workers are being paid for 'completing tasks'.
As a beginner like myself, yep. But certainly not for those who wish to make money from their artwork.I might be wrong but I believe that copying others' styles helps you develop your own style (requires quite a bit of talent too though).
Any designer wants to be innovative, that's what designing is all about. It's about using your imagination.I suppose you are speaking about a very experienced designer/architect, well, it's logical that the better you work, the more freedom you'll get.
Absolutely, but there's no choice involved. Those people have to work by commands to get money.Well, perhaps they might not like it, but it's the way things work isn't it? People do have to get by.
What's the difference then? If you start making money once you've developped your style completely it might be just too late tbh.Xenon said:As a beginner like myself, yep. But certainly not for those who wish to make money from their artwork.
Since we've started talking about money, then I believe it's more important that the designer's client like his work - which means a designer should follow all the instructions given by the client. Then use his own imagination to make it as good as possible, yes.Xenon said:Any designer wants to be innovative, that's what designing is all about. It's about using your imagination.