Rayman 1

GOT4N · Post by **GOT4N** » Mon Oct 20, 2014 12:52 pm

Sorry for the bad editing quality I was 9 years old, also, it works on all versions, but I was in a country where connection was very low, so I used GBA version lol

Adsolution · Post by **Adsolution** » Fri Oct 24, 2014 11:13 pm

This is a month and a half old, but I somehow missed all responses to it:

Rayfist wrote:
Adsolution wrote:For note, I'll never pick the Saturn version, because some of the background changes were nonsensical, and almost all the sound effects are stupidly pitched-up to the point where they sound like Atari 2600 samples, which honestly kills it for me.
Oh come on, is it really not worth it? It might not be everyones favorite version but avoiding at all costs? I think Spiral above me described it perfectly. It's actually far better than the PC port (aside from the missing beginning intro to Band Land). PS1 and Saturn version for the win. The background swaps may not be to your liking but at least it adds something a little different. And I felt some areas actually had much proper background replacements. Avoiding the Saturn version completely is kind of silly in my opinion. :/

The little Windows movie maker transitions for loading screens was kind of a nice touch as well, nothing outstanding, but cool. It's not at all expensive like the Jaguar version, so avoiding it really confuses me, as the SEGA Saturn was a 2D beast. SEGA and Rayman was always proven to be an awesome combination.

Where in the world did I say "avoid at all costs"? I said for the reasons above it will never be my favourite version of Rayman 1. I sort of go by "a version is only as strong as its weakest link". When the sound effects are the most butchered out of all the versions, whereas the inprovements relative to the prominence and quality of the sound effects are less significant in my own opinion, it hardly has a shot at being my favourite. There are exceptions, not even ultra-rare ones, but yeah. Given this, I'd have to say that the PS1 version is my favourite.

spiraldoor wrote:Some of the background changes were great though. Extending the moon background of the final Space Mama battle to the previous stage and giving it those scrolling layers was a stroke of genius, and greatly adds to the cohesion and atmosphere of the level, particularly considering the choice of music.

I'd actually comoletely forgotten about that one.

I take back most of what I've said about the backgrounds. Some of the changes were "nonsensical", but that doesn't mean they were bad necessarily, they created a different atmosphere. Though I'd say for the most part, I preferred the originals. One thing I found very interesting was how in the Saturn version, the stormy area in Pocture City used the "stormy" background from Band Land, I thought that was also a great choice.

The sound effects still kill a lot of it for me though. The original game didn't have stupendous sound design by any means, but what were they thinking?

Rayfist · Post by **Rayfist** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 7:04 am

Adsolution wrote:Where in the world did I say "avoid at all costs"? I said for the reasons above it will never be my favourite version of Rayman 1

Didn't we discuss this on skype? Jesus.

Adsolution · Post by **Adsolution** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 8:26 am

Don't think so. I'm also just making sure you didn't misinterpret that post in particular.

A little abrasive with the "Jesus", non?

Fifo · Post by **Fifo** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 9:33 am

Wow, take a look:

Snagglebee · Post by **Snagglebee** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:22 am

Fifo wrote:Wow, take a look:

Composite still stinks on normal CRT TV. What are you waiting for? Just get a RGB cable

and lol glitch.

Fifo · Post by **Fifo** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:32 am

emshomar wrote:Composite still stinks on normal CRT TV. What are you waiting for? Just get a RGB cable :P
and lol glitch.

I don’t care about quality. Why spend additional money for a RGB SCART cable? :P

Snagglebee · Post by **Snagglebee** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:41 am

Fifo wrote:I don’t care about quality. Why spend additional money for a RGB SCART cable?

Because composite looks unbearable on modern HDTVs, espacially on mine and I think 5€ is a good investement to get a clean nice picture which your TV deserves!

Shrooblord · Post by **Shrooblord** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:46 am

I wonder how you find those old posts, sometimes, Ad.

Fifo · Post by **Fifo** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:50 am

emshomar wrote:
Fifo wrote:I don’t care about quality. Why spend additional money for a RGB SCART cable?
Composite looks unbearable on modern HDTVs

I use an old CRT TV; PS1 games were meant to be played on CRT TVs, not HDTVs. Playing on an HDTV shows the overscan area and black bars, which is a little annoying, and I hate stretching games to 16:9.

saerleiya · Post by **saerleiya** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:51 am

Fifo wrote:I use an old CRT TV; PS1 games were meant to be played on CRT TVs, not HDTVs. Playing on an HDTV shows the overscan area and black bars, which is a little annoying, and I hate stretching games to 16:9.

Yes, kinda: playing on a good CRT TV is not that bad. The quality is still okay nowadays. Some of them are just terrible to play on.

Snagglebee · Post by **Snagglebee** » Sat Oct 25, 2014 10:53 am

Fifo wrote:Playing on an HDTV shows the overscan area and black bars, which is a little annoying,

At least on my HDTV, I still got the possibility to have overscan

Fifo wrote:and I hate stretching games to 16:9.

And I yet can keep the aspect on 4:3

Rayfist · Post by **Rayfist** » Sun Oct 26, 2014 1:53 am

Adsolution wrote:Don't think so. I'm also just making sure you didn't misinterpret that post in particular.

A little abrasive with the "Jesus", non?

Sorry, was kind of upset that day, but yes, I'm 100% positive we did discuss that. The "Jesus" was just to express that I really didn't think you had to make such a long reply at a problem I supposebly thought had been already solved is all I'm saying.

spiraldoor · Post by **spiraldoor** » Sun Oct 26, 2014 3:57 pm

Adsolution wrote:I take back most of what I've said about the backgrounds. Some of the changes were "nonsensical", but that doesn't mean they were bad necessarily, they created a different atmosphere. Though I'd say for the most part, I preferred the originals. One thing I found very interesting was how in the Saturn version, the stormy area in Pocture City used the "stormy" background from Band Land, I thought that was also a great choice.

I just went to YouTube to compare them for myself, and it turns out you're mistaken: the Saturn version uses the rainbows/painted mountains background for the storm level, while the PS1 version uses the Band Land storm background. The latter, which I grew up with, has the nice effect of creating an unexpected cohesion between the two worlds. The former works well too thanks to its use of the "storm filter" (for want of a better term), which creates a unique identity for the level when applied to the rainbow background. I'm not sure which I prefer.

Rayfist wrote:Sorry, was kind of upset that day, but yes, I'm 100% positive we did discuss that. The "Jesus" was just to express that I really didn't think you had to make such a long reply at a problem I supposebly thought had been already solved is all I'm saying.

I haven't been following this dispute but your reaction to "long replies" strikes me as a tiny bit anti-intellectual...

Adsolution · Post by **Adsolution** » Sun Oct 26, 2014 10:01 pm

Oh wow, my memory is anything but cohesive. One thing's for sure, I need to play through the Saturn version again.

The "storm filter" always bugged me a little bit in areas where there was clearly a lot of blue sky, but it is a nice effect, and exrtra layer of clouds for them I think would've added a lot. I'm actually curious as to why they didn't make more use of filters in general, they could have done wonders for night lighting and such.

Haruka · Post by **Haruka** » Sun Oct 26, 2014 10:33 pm

I never played the Saturn version in its totality (and it was only through emulation) but it is particularly notable for having different visual effects or backgrounds. I don't remember everything but I remember to have seen in Cairnie's walkthrough that the last phase before Space Mama's battle in Space Mama's Crater has got the same background (the sidescrolling space). It makes much more sense than in other platforms in my opinion. And there's the nice detail of the shattering vitrals of Mr. Dark's hideout after his defeat.

Rayfist · Post by **Rayfist** » Sun Oct 26, 2014 11:20 pm

Spiraldoor wrote:I haven't been following this dispute but your reaction to "long replies" strikes me as a tiny bit anti-intellectual...

I'm not doubting you here but I don't know if it's exactly fair to judge, as this hasn't been to common with other members, only select few. If it seems I'm replying negatively towards Ad, in often making a silly one liner. We are in no way, arguing. Though Ad has pointed to me in the past that I need to chill with the abrasiveness. You said yourself you really haven't been following the dispute, me and Ad talked about it on SKYPE for a bit, he seems to have forgotten which is okay, I reminded. The unnecesary abrasiveness on my part has been noted though. The "intellectual" part of the argument was discussed over skype, and it's over, I was simply reminding. Sorry, I wasn't trying to criticize or shut anyone up. I might have misinterpreted your reply, so forgive me.

Shrooblord · Post by **Shrooblord** » Mon Oct 27, 2014 12:36 am

I think the point is rather that you brought an argument you two were having here and then shut it up immediately. If you're gonna involve us, involve us. Don't incite and immediately thereafter kill conversation and/or discussion. I assume that's what spiral meant with that comment (fighting intellectual discussion by killing it as it sprouts).

Rayfist · Post by **Rayfist** » Mon Oct 27, 2014 12:40 am

I'll try to avoid that for future reference. It's not like I don't want to have any sort of conversation i just saw not much reason to further discuss since the problem had technically been dealt with.

Shrooblord · Post by **Shrooblord** » Mon Oct 27, 2014 12:43 am

Uhuh, totally understandable. But if we're gonna discuss things, at least let us join in and say our part.

Rayman Pirate-Community

Rayman 1

Which version is your favourite?

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1

Re: Rayman 1