Talk:The Magician: Difference between revisions

Line 146:

Given the arguments presented in [https://raymanpc.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=75447 this topic], and the consensus that appears to have emerged, I would like to suggest a split of this article into one for the Rayman 1 Magician and one for the Rayman Origins Magician, given the lack of compelling evidence that they are indeed the same character. The wiki would adopt the position that the relationship between the two is unclear, without excluding any possibilities. Any thoughts? —[[File:RRRGBAIcon8.png|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]][[File:RRRGBAIcon0.gif|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]][[File:RRRGBAIcon1.png|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]] 17:59, 2 October 2024 (CEST)

:Hmm, I personally wouldn't split the article to avoid confusion between two Magicians as it's fine as it is, as least in my opinion, but it would be nice to clarify about their relationship between each other is unclear. --[[User:Strangesolo|Strangesolo]] ([[User talk:Strangesolo|talk]]) 09:53, 3 October 2024 (CEST)

::If we cannot establish for sure that they are one and the same, then I believe we should split the article, with a disambiguation disclaimer at the top and a paragraph at the end of the article headers to explain that the relationship is unclear. It would be less confusing to me, and more consistent with [[Dark Rayman|Rayman's evil clones]]. --[[User:Hoodlumsworld|Hoodlumsworld]] ([[User talk:Hoodlumsworld|talk]]) 21:27, 3 October 2024 (CEST)

@@ Line 146: / Line 146: @@
 Given the arguments presented in [https://raymanpc.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=75447 this topic], and the consensus that appears to have emerged, I would like to suggest a split of this article into one for the Rayman 1 Magician and one for the Rayman Origins Magician, given the lack of compelling evidence that they are indeed the same character. The wiki would adopt the position that the relationship between the two is unclear, without excluding any possibilities. Any thoughts? —[[File:RRRGBAIcon8.png|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]][[File:RRRGBAIcon0.gif|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]][[File:RRRGBAIcon1.png|class=sprite|link=User:Hunchman801]] 17:59, 2 October 2024 (CEST)
 :Hmm, I personally wouldn't split the article to avoid confusion between two Magicians as it's fine as it is, as least in my opinion, but it would be nice to clarify about their relationship between each other is unclear. --[[User:Strangesolo|Strangesolo]] ([[User talk:Strangesolo|talk]]) 09:53, 3 October 2024 (CEST)
+::If we cannot establish for sure that they are one and the same, then I believe we should split the article, with a disambiguation disclaimer at the top and a paragraph at the end of the article headers to explain that the relationship is unclear. It would be less confusing to me, and more consistent with [[Dark Rayman|Rayman's evil clones]]. --[[User:Hoodlumsworld|Hoodlumsworld]] ([[User talk:Hoodlumsworld|talk]]) 21:27, 3 October 2024 (CEST)