Talk:The Magician: Difference between revisions
| Line 151: | Line 151: | ||
::::From what's been discussed in the forums, my takeaway is that there's enough doubt in that it's never stated outright that the Magician in Rayman Origins is the same as the Magician from Rayman 1, as was done for other returning characters. While the script isn't canonical it does imply a sense that the Magician wasn't intended to be the same, now we can't take that as canonical fact, but we can at least gleam some authorial intent. Combine that with no explicit link mentioned by the authors, and I think while there's no canonical evidence for a link or no link either ways, there is enough to justify us keeping them as separate entities until a future game or future information proves otherwise. Or put simply, we can't definitively prove they are the same, but we can't prove that they are different either, and the safer option is probably to assume they're different but mention the possibility of being the same, but explain the ambiguity. --[[User:Master|Master]] ([[User talk:Master|talk]]) 18:23, 4 October 2024 (CEST) | ::::From what's been discussed in the forums, my takeaway is that there's enough doubt in that it's never stated outright that the Magician in Rayman Origins is the same as the Magician from Rayman 1, as was done for other returning characters. While the script isn't canonical it does imply a sense that the Magician wasn't intended to be the same, now we can't take that as canonical fact, but we can at least gleam some authorial intent. Combine that with no explicit link mentioned by the authors, and I think while there's no canonical evidence for a link or no link either ways, there is enough to justify us keeping them as separate entities until a future game or future information proves otherwise. Or put simply, we can't definitively prove they are the same, but we can't prove that they are different either, and the safer option is probably to assume they're different but mention the possibility of being the same, but explain the ambiguity. --[[User:Master|Master]] ([[User talk:Master|talk]]) 18:23, 4 October 2024 (CEST) | ||
:::::I certainly believe that the two characters are different, and I don’t know why there is an ongoing belief that there are 2 separate characters. | |||
:::::Overall, I think there should be a split, or at least an acknowledgement that they are different on the wiki | |||
ambiguity. --[[User:Greengoop|Greengoop]] ([[User talk:Greengoop|talk]]) | |||