Hunchman801
Administrator
- Messages
- 87,892
- Tings
- 641,337
By the way, there hasn't been any official communication about the 30th Anniversary Edition music, but it's an open secret that it comes down to a rights issue with some of the tracks. It looks like Rémi's tracks were remade while staying pretty close to the originals, whereas the tracks from the other composers were replaced with entirely new ones that have nothing to do with the previous ones.
My understanding is that French copyright law primarily protects the individual (the actual human being who created the work) and doesn't automatically grant a company ownership of the music created for them. So, if you want to reuse the game's original soundtrack, you have to sign a new contract with the composers.
And that's where things get complicated. My theory is that for some of these tracks, nobody actually knows who composed them anymore. That makes them "orphan works", which would create a massive liability for Ubi if the original author suddenly woke up and demanded damages for the illegal use of their IP.
So they had to replace part of the music with entirely new compositions, and to keep the whole thing cohesive, they remade Rémi's music without changing it too much (they probably made a deal with his family).
It's just a theory, and I don't know why this problem popped up with the 30th Anniversary Edition and not Rayman Classic, but it doesn't seem completely crazy to me.
My understanding is that French copyright law primarily protects the individual (the actual human being who created the work) and doesn't automatically grant a company ownership of the music created for them. So, if you want to reuse the game's original soundtrack, you have to sign a new contract with the composers.
And that's where things get complicated. My theory is that for some of these tracks, nobody actually knows who composed them anymore. That makes them "orphan works", which would create a massive liability for Ubi if the original author suddenly woke up and demanded damages for the illegal use of their IP.
So they had to replace part of the music with entirely new compositions, and to keep the whole thing cohesive, they remade Rémi's music without changing it too much (they probably made a deal with his family).
It's just a theory, and I don't know why this problem popped up with the 30th Anniversary Edition and not Rayman Classic, but it doesn't seem completely crazy to me.