Talk:Carnivora
Gender?
I noticed that the gender was changed from female to male. Is there any evidence supporting either claim? --
21:24, 26 February 2018 (UTC)
- The French and Spanish wikis have it listed as female, though I'm not sure what the arguments are in favor of one or the other. —
16:27, 18 March 2020 (CET)
- Carnivora (formerly Daisy) is considered as a female since the creation of the French page (not by me).
- If I remember correctly the discussion on the French wiki about the Four Kings, that's because Carnivora is a flower, and "Carnivora" sounds like a girl name (and "Daisy" is a girl name).
- But is that enough?
- It's possible that there are queens among the Four Kings. For reminder, the Mocking Bird is a female. But we have a good argument for this boss, since she lays eggs. --Boomboleros7 00:16, 19 March 2020 (CET)
- In the absence of any further clues, I think it might be best to list her gender as 'unknown' on all wikis. — 12:02, 19 March 2020 (CET)
- I changed it to female for now since the French side claims this, and it's more likely considering "Daisy" as mentioned above. However, if this seems incorrect, we can change the gender to unknown, and I can change all corresponding mentions of it to gender neutral ones. It's worth noting that Poor Little Daisy said both him and her, so the article contradicted itself anyway. --
22:46, 13 June 2020 (CEST)
- I changed it to female for now since the French side claims this, and it's more likely considering "Daisy" as mentioned above. However, if this seems incorrect, we can change the gender to unknown, and I can change all corresponding mentions of it to gender neutral ones. It's worth noting that Poor Little Daisy said both him and her, so the article contradicted itself anyway. --
- In the absence of any further clues, I think it might be best to list her gender as 'unknown' on all wikis. —
Names
It's not obvious to me that "daisy" and "giant plant" should be listed as alternate names. While they obviously refer to Carnivora, they are used in a descriptive manner (yes, Carnivora is a daisy and a giant plant) but do not necessarily imply that they are the creature's name. In fact, "daisy" is just a species name and "giant plant" an even broader categorization. It's a bit like saying that Globox's alternate name is Frog because he is at some point referred to as a frog. What do you guys think? — 11:20, 1 March 2025 (UTC)